Brave Rifles: The Problem of a Godless Army

by | 15 Dec, 2017 | 2 comments

I love God. I love the Army. The collusion of these two drove me to write Brave Rifles.

But something is wrong…

A View from the Front

In 2013, the Army sent me to my first ever divisional assignment and to say that it opened my eyes was a mild euphemism. I cherished my three years in the unit, though I never expected to encounter the affliction that has become so unfortunately common.

But, I loved it. I loved the soldiers, earnest young men and women, many of whom truly wanted to make a difference in this world. It wasn’t lost on me that nearly all of them enlisted after September 11th knowing that a deployment to combat was likely imminent at some point. I loved the NCO’s, a magnificent group of seasoned and respected sergeants who served as the glue that held things together when they seemed likely to fall apart. I loved the officers, a group of committed young patriots—bright, energetic, and motivated. The lieutenants and captains are light-years ahead of where I was at a similar point in my career.

Yet, something was wrong. I could tell from the beginning, but could not diagnose the issue. I observed and watched. As a Battalion Commander and then the rear detachment Brigade Commander of over 3,000 soldiers, I had a front-row seat to the action. And as I observed, I deliberated. Something was amiss, but I could not quite fathom what. Lots of symptoms, but what was the source?

Walking around, you would never know something was wrong. Soldiers looked just about the same as they always looked. Our Brigade performed magnificently in combat, yet two things consistently captured my attention: the sheer breadth of affliction within the ranks and the yeoman’s efforts of commanders and 1SG’s in addressing the affliction. 

The Standard

The Army has always prided itself on being a values-based organization, insisting upon integrity at all levels. We drill the Army Values of,

– Loyalty
– Duty
– Respect
– Selfless Service
– Honor
– Integrity
– Personal Courage

into the heads of new soldiers from the first day of basic training. The Army Values are good, all necessary to build trust, an essential component in combat and to a self-professed values-based organization. Interestingly, the Army Values could have been lifted straight from the pages of Scripture. Were I to biblically expound the attributes of a soldier, they would probably look a lot like the Army Values.

Further, the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) supports the ethos of the Army, reinforcing that which the Army declared important. Thus, things that may not be an issue in the civilian world will quickly have you running afoul of Army leadership. As an example, the Army maintains, for now anyway, a well-defined sexual ethic. Adultery violates the UCMJ. Now, it’s exceedingly difficult to prove adultery, as a commander literally needs a confession, a positive blood test on a child, or some other ‘proof’ of the act. Yet, it is against the UCMJ and soldiers may be punished if found guilty of committing adultery.

Again, this and other aspects of the UCMJ could have been lifted straight from the pages of the Bible. The Army Values, the Warrior Ethos, the UCMJ: these all serve as a rudder, guarding the hearts and actions of soldiers and serving as the anchor for the entire organization. Against this backdrop, I’ve labored over company commanders, 1SG’s, and the impossible tasks the Army demands of them. 

The Problem

We had a senior Army leader visit the installation, and as a Brigade-level leader I was privileged to attend a forum with him and the other commanders. He remarked that every commander and 1SG on every installation that he visited remarked that the Army required way more of them than there was time to do. An issue as long as I’ve been in the Army, the literal requirements placed upon company level leadership greatly outpaced their capacity (time) to complete these requirements.

Wong and Gerras from the War College drew upon some of this analysis as for years, the Army reported ‘all complete’ on extraneous requirements out of one side of its mouth yet with the other, complained that there was not enough time in the day to accomplish all of the necessary tasks. Well, which was it?

This particular senior leader believed the issue to be one of prioritization. The commanders should prioritize their requirements, obtain buy-in from their leadership, and then execute what they are able. Allow their senior leaders to provide top-cover on requirements deemed untenable or unnecessary based upon time and resources available.

This may brief well, but I wondered to myself if this would work. I never did such a thing as a company commander. As a battalion commander, none of my company commanders had done such a thing. As a rear detachment brigade commander, none of my battalion commanders had come forward in such a fashion. Every unit I’ve been a part of reported ‘all complete’ when it was just never feasible to have completed but a fraction of the required tasks.

In assessing this senior leader’s remarks, I determined that most company commanders probably don’t have time for that level of assessment. Company commanders exist on the front lines of leadership, literally where the rubber meets the road. To take time to make a comparable assessment is not feasible for most. Perhaps it should have been the higher headquarters that made this type of assessment. Besides, most things seemed like a priority. How would you prioritize when your headquarters deemed numerous competing demands as priorities?

I had a company commander sleeping at the CQ desk for several nights in a row keeping watch over an imminently suicidal soldier. I had a company commander spend several sequential days dealing with a love triangle in the motor pool. I had a company commander make so many trips to the local mental health facility where we sent struggling soldiers that he became known by name.

These are all good things in that commanders get paid to take care of soldiers and concern themselves with their well-being. On the other hand, we also pay commanders to accomplish the mission, to close with and destroy the enemy, to fight and win our nation’s wars, and every hour, every day, every week spent dealing with the litany of soldier issues is time NOT spent preparing their units for the rigors of combat. Here is the issue.

The Army standard is clearly a godly standard, whether intentional or not, though I believe it to be intentional. The Army, as it reflects the composition of our society writ large, is clearly and increasingly a godless organization. The primary challenge facing leaders in the modern Army of the United States is this,

motivating godly behavior from the godless, apart from God.

Herein lies the crux of the leadership challenge with which the Army wrestles. Allow me to explain. The challenge is, motivating godly behavior (compliance with UCMJ and internalization of the Army Values and Warrior Ethos) from the godless (majority of soldiers), apart from God (in an environment hostile to the intentional proliferation of the Gospel).

My previous commander, one of the greatest combat leaders I’ve ever had the privilege of serving under, remains convinced that the United States is poised for a fall and that we will lose our next war. I am not sure if I concur. However, virtually every issue the leaders of our Army grapple with stems from the impossibility of the above paradigm. One can only coax a certain measure of godliness from the godless. Failure is inevitable in this regard.

Frankly, the issue is sin running in opposition to values and codes which generates all manner of personal affliction in the lives of soldiers.

Sin necessitates mandatory training in an attempt to handle the issue from a secular standing.

The resonate sin in our force, not under the conviction of the Holy Spirit or increasingly not even under the common grace of the proliferation of the Gospel, consumes our force and its leaders, diverting them from the most important of tasks—preparing our forces to confront the evil of this world.

We must come to terms with this while we can. We don’t have much time.

2 Comments

  1. Joe

    Hello! Insightful post, but to be honest the end got me a bit confused. What you are lamenting is the loss of regeneration in the bulk of the troops, correct? While I’m not a military man and so only have a seat in the cheap seats, I am thinking your observations are probably dead-on as what you are describing is a reflection of our culture as a whole. However, is there any way to fabricate or imitate regeneration in the hearts of men aside from the working of the Holy Spirit? Surely not! Jeremiah 31 and Ezekiel 36 make it clear that it’s a divine hand that does this. With this being the case, I think the problem is much bigger than you describe in your closing. We do indeed need to be worried about being able to confront the forces of evil, but with no regeneration, no touch of the divine accomplished through the gospel’s acceptance, our first problem is this; how do we avoid becoming the force of evil ourselves? A nation, and her military, set against God, unregenerate, and manufacturing an arbitrary morality is destined to become nothing less as far as I can see.
    I paint a dark picture but it isn’t one I’m ready to brace as inevitable just yet. The solution is the same as it’s always been, the gospel! We need fearless men and women to preach the true gospel of Christ regardless of consequence for the glory of God with an eye to a bigger picture than just their own personal situation.
    Again, my view from the cheap seats…..

    Reply
    • Bradford Smith

      Joe, great comments! Sorry for the late response. Yes and yes! The ultimate issue, which I intend to get to in the series is the widespread spiritual darkness in our forces and ultimately in our nation. I hope to exhort men to examine themselves spiritually in light of the pervasive godlessness, that and proclaim Christ and Him crucified.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Bradford Smith

Bradford Smith

Author - Founder

Soldier, Pastor, Author – Bradford stays busy, with his wife Ami, raising their 9 children, serving the nation, pastoring, preaching, and writing books (#3 is due out October ’17).

THE 413 REPORT

If you loved this article, and would like to learn more about foster and adoption care, and to stay up to date on our projects, missions, and programs, as well as the release of Bradford's third book, Brave Rifles, please sign up for our Newsletter. The 413 Project is made up of common people empowering and serving others to accomplish an uncommon good.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

This is a powerful read in a small book. The subtitle hits the mark with its description of, "A Biblical Treatise on Adoption." The author poses a challenge to the reader to stop reading the book upfront if the reader does not want to be moved to action.

   Janice S. Garey  

The call that sounds for the incredible need of emotionally and physically abandoned and orphaned children and one that when answered manifests the love of Christ.

  Anne Rightler

This book is a must read for anyone affected in any way by addictions. So many of the situations in this book seem hopeless, but as Brad so clearly points out, Christ is the solution and the only hope of man. As long as there is breath, there is hope!

  Scott Doherty

In Scourge, Brad offers us more than cold statistics or a cautionary tale. Instead, he offers us the solution - faith backed by action - to overcome this insidious problem Insightful and provocative, Scourge is a warning flag, guide post and rally to hope for all of us.

 Chad Chasteen

Share This
%d bloggers like this: